One short program event down, three to go. While waking up at 4 a.m. wasn’t the ideal situation, the men’s short program competition was worth it, I must say. Even from the first group, there were highlights. Of course, the real fireworks came later on when the favorites hit the ice and they did not disappoint!
Not much was expected of the inexperienced American team in Moscow. Richard Dornbush and Ross Miner are at their first Worlds, and Ryan Bradley, who has been there twice before — unsuccessfully — has said this is the first time he feels like he belongs.
Dornbush and Miner both skated in the first group and were more than clean — they were quite lovely to watch! I felt Miner’s PCS scores were a bit low, but they both hit the 70+ mark and had a lot to be proud of.
Bradley skated first in the third group, and from the get go, I could tell he was nervous. He hit two quad toe-triple toe combinations in the warm up, but in the program, it was a quad-double. Still, he hit a HUGE triple axel and a nice triple flip. The crowd wasn’t eating him up like normal, so it felt a little flatter than it should have. But it was a good, strong, clean skate. He was underscored, in my ever so humble opinion.
Denis Ten was quite a pleasant surprise. He led the field from the first group up until the second-to-last group with a solid 71+ score. He’s made some dramatic improvements with Frank Carroll. I wonder, though, if he can hold it together for a long program.
The Frenchmen Florent Amodio and Brian Joubert skated back to back.
Amodio was cool, calm, controlled…and explosive. He laid down a great skate. No quad, but he easily took the lead.
Joubert was good…not great. And while he had a quad (that he turned out of), he had no combination. This should have been a serious deduction. His technical elements score was lower than Bradley, but his components score was higher by about 5 points. As much as I love Brian, that was not right. I would have Brian/Ryan’s programs about equal. Brian with perhaps a slight edge in PCS — but slight. That is, if Brian has all the elements. Without a combo, he shouldn’t have led. I feel the international judges don’t take Bradley seriously, probably partly due to his comedic routines. But that doesn’t make his skills any less significant.
But I digress.
Takahiko Kozuka skated after winning the Qualifying Round and proved that he’s quite a contender. I still cringe at this short program, but he skated it well with only a minor error on his triple axel.
Daisuke Takahashi and Patrick Chan stole the night, though. These two have been the co-favorites all along, and they proved why.
Chan skated first, and he laid down the gauntlet with a textbook quad toe-triple toe, triple axel, and a triple lutz. Add that to his impeccable basic skating, creative transitions and best-in-the-world footwork, and we have a winner! He set the new world record short program score, taking down that of previous record-holder Plushenko (who was in the building to see it go down!). It was truly something special. And one of the few programs I felt deserved the scores it received!
Takahashi was wonderful as well. He didn’t have a quad, but what he had was heart. People were moved by his performance, and not just because he skated it well. To come through the trials his country is coming through and to skate with that much focus and skill…just brilliant. His scores didn’t reflect the quality of his skate, and he finds himself some 13 points behind Chan (who is rightfully in first, but Dai was incredible as well).
Michal Brezina’s scores baffled me a bit, as did Artur Gachinski’s…and even Tomas Verner’s. It almost appeared like the old 6.0 system that because these three skated later in the event, the judges scored them higher. Now, in the old system, they had to save scores for the later groups. Not so anymore. Or so it is supposed to be.
These three compared to the three Americans (and Denis Ten) weren’t all that impressive. Certainly not 7 points more impressive. Brezina struggled on his combo and lacked some polish and quality throughout. Gachinski’s quad-triple combo was impressive, but the rest was just average. Verner’s short program is to die for, but even “Singing in the Rain” couldn’t mask the fall on his quad attempt or the struggle with his combination. And yet, there they are, all at least 6 points higher than those with comparable skates early on. *sigh* Maybe the judges will never learn.
Nobunari Oda was the last to skate, and he had some demons to fight. Last year at worlds he had a disastrous short program and ended up 28th overall in the event. He certainly made up for that here. But yet again, the scores baffled me. His program shouldn’t have compared to Takahashi’s, and yet he found himself between Patrick and Daisuke and in second place headed to the free skate.
I must say, this was a very entertaining event thanks to the athletes. It was quite frustrating and even confounding thanks to the judges. I’m obviously not a judge. But I think I know good skating when I see it, and the placements after the shorts don’t reflect the best skates of the night (err, early morning here!).
Regardless, the stage is set. Chan looks to have a comfortable enough lead that he should skate with less pressure. Takahashi, Oda and Kozuka will be battling it out for medals, but they won’t be alone. Less than 5 points separate 2nd-6th. Plus, there are just over 5.5 points difference from 8th-13th.
Oh, the games are just beginning!
Here are your complete results after the Short Programs.
- Patrick Chan (CAN) 93.02
- Nobunari Oda (JPN) 81.81
- Daisuke Takahashi (JPN) 80.25
- Artur Gachinski (RUS) 78.34
- Florent Amodio (FRA) 77.64
- Takahiko Kozuka (JPN) 77.62
- Michal Brezina (CZE) 77.50
- Tomas Verner (CZE) 75.94
- Brian Joubert (FRA) 71.29
- Denis Ten (KAZ) 71.00
- Richard Dornbush (USA) 70.54
- Ryan Bradley (USA) 70.45
- Ross Miner (USA) 70.40
- Javier Fernandez (ESP) 69.16
- Kevin Van Der Perren (BEL) 68.34
- Peter Liebers (GER) 67.73
- Anton Kovalevski (UKR) 65.16
- Samuel Contesti (ITA) 64.59
- Kevin Reynolds (CAN) 64.36
- Nan Song (CHN) 64.78
- Joey Russell (CAN) 61.69
- Jorik Hendrickx (BEL) 60.74
- Paolo Bacchini (ITA) 58.96
- Kim Lucine (MON) 58.81
- Adrian Schultheiss (SWE) 58.41*
- Viktor Pfeifer (AUT) 56.68*
- Min-Seok Kim (KOR) 56.19*
- Alexander Majorov (SWE) 54.24*
- Maxim Shipov (ISR) 50.10*
- Misha Ge (UZB) 49.61*